aarogya.com
  • Home
  • Complementary Medicine
    • Ayurveda
    • Homeopathy
    • Naturopathy
    • Acupressure
    • Acupuncture
    • Aromatherapy
    • Batch Flower Remedies
    • Home Remedies
    • Massage
    • Yoga
    • Meditation
    • Reiki
    • Bodywork
    • Medical Palmistry
  • Conditions & Diseases
    • Acute Diarrheal Disease
    • Appendicitis
    • Blindness
    • Brucellosis
    • Chicken Pox
    • Conjunctivitis
    • Dysentery
    • Hookworm
    • Japanese Encephalitis
    • Lymphatic Filariasis
    • Plague
    • Rubella
    • Typhoid Fever
    • Yellow Fever
    • Allergy
    • Arthritis
    • Blood Pressure
    • Computer Health Hazards
    • Chikungunya Fever
    • Dengue
    • Guinea Worm
    • Influenza
    • Leprosy
    • Malaria
    • Poliomyelitis
    • Tetanus
    • Whooping Cough
    • Viral Hepatitis
    • Amebiasis
    • Asthma
    • Bronchitis
    • Diagnostic Tests
    • Cholera
    • Diphtheria
    • Hepatitis
    • Irritable Bowel Syndrome
    • Leptospirosis
    • Measles
    • Rabies
    • Tuberculosis
    • Yaws
  • Family Health
    • Children's Health
    • Diet & Nutrition
    • First Aid
    • Fitness
    • Humor & Trivia
    • Men's Health
    • Preventive Health
    • Senior's Health
    • Senior Citizen Corner
    • Teen’s Health
    • Vets and Pets
    • Women’s Health
  • Health Resources
    • Blood Donation
    • Career Opportunities
    • Daily Health Tips
    • Health Programs
    • Featured Hospitals
    • Medical Education
    • Health Professional's Negligence
    • Medical Tourism
    • Video Eye
    • Rural Health
    • Patients' Rights Forum
  • Insurance
    • Euthanasia
    • Health Insurance
    • Health Insurance Policies
    • Insurance Companies
    • Medical Ethics
    • Medical Jurisprudence
    • Research
    • Telemedicine
    • Compare Health Insurance
  • Sex & Sexuality
    • What is Sex & Sexuality?
    • FAQs
    • Marriage & Pregnancy
    • Sex Education
  • Support Groups
    • Addiction
    • Aids
    • Cancer
    • Epilepsy
    • Swine Flu
    • Blood Search
    • Vivah
    • Health Directory
    • Alzheimer's Disease
    • Medical Support Groups
    • Cardiology
    • Depression
    • Depression Screening Test
    • Diabetes
    • Disability
    • Kidney
    • Obesity
    • Pregnancy
    • Schizophrenia
    • Vitiligo
Aarogya.com
Marathi | Gujarati | Register | Login
  • Home
  • News and Updates
  • Year 2010
  • Small Doses, Big Cures?

Small Doses, Big Cures?

  • Print
Details
Hits: 2938
Times of India
17 March 2010
By Pronoti Datta

Sweet Talk
Why does homoeopathy, which was founded in Europe, draw a lesser response there than in India, which has the most widespread practice in the world? An ongoing homoeopathy exhibition tells all
Sweet Talk Sweet Talk
There’s an amusing anecdote, quoted in Dipesh Chakrabarty’s Habitations of Modernity, involving novelist Saratchandra Chatterjee and nationalist leaders Sarat Bose and Anilbaran Ray. The story hinges on their attitudes to khadi, the symbol of resistance to colonial rule. While Bose preferred finely spun khadi, Ray wore coarse khadi to show his fervid dedication to the cause. Taking a dig at khadi-wearing nationalists, Chatterjee said: “You see, we have all different kinds here. A little variety is a good thing. Anil is the mother tincture (of khadi), while Sarat is two hundred per cent dilution.’’

Chakraborty’s homoeopathy metaphor was very natural in a city which Martin Dinges, deputy director at Germany’s Institute for the History of Medicine of the Robert Bosch Foundation (IHM), calls “the real powerhouse’’ of the alternative medicine form. Speaking at the ongoing exhibition put together by Navi Mumbai’s Association for Research in Homeopathy (ARH), Max Mueller Bhavan and IHM, Dinges and other speakers traced the history of homoeopathy and why India took to it instantly.

German physician Samuel Hahnemann founded the practice in the late eighteenth century, and soon after, it travelled to India in the medicine kits of European doctors and missionaries. The country got its first dose of homeopathy around the 1830s through John Honigberger, a Hungarian doctor who had studied under Hahnemann. Honigberger treated Lahore’s Maharaja Ranjit Singh, whose vocal chords were paralysed, and, according to some accounts, the ruler’s favourite horse, which was afflicted by an ulcer. Impressed, the maharaja allowed Honigberger to open a sort of outpatient department in Lahore.

One of the first homeopaths to practice in Mumbai was Vishveshwar Kulkarni, who started a pharmacy, Roy and Co, in 1889 after learning the subject from a Jesuit priest in Karnataka. His great grandson, Dr Jeetendra Kulkarni, runs the shop on Princess Street and claims that his family pioneered homeopathy in western Maharashtra. Kulkarni bore the title Rao, which became the anglicised Roy.

According to Robert Jütte, director o f IHM, Indians quickly adopted homeopathy, as it is similar in some ways to ayurveda and unani medicine—all three have remedies made from natural products. “It was a bridge between the European and Indian world,’’ he explains. Initially, it was the “medication for infectious diseases, so it was perfect for India where cholera and malaria were common’’. The practice has grown to such an extent, Jütte says, that 13 per cent of all physicians in India are homeopaths. Next on the scale is Brazil, in which about 4 per cent of physicians are homeopaths. Dr R K Manchanda, deputy director (homeopathy) in Delhi government’s directorate of Indian Systems of Medicine and Homeopathy estimates that thanks to financial and legislative support from the government—homeopathy was officially recognised by the state in 1973—there are 185 homeopathy colleges inIndia and more than two lakh doctors.

While India has taken to the alternative medicine like a duck to water, it is severely criticised in the UK. In February, the House of Commons Science and Technology Committee declared that the government should no longer fund homeopathy, as there was no scientific evidence to suggest that it worked better than placebos. Homeopaths argue that it’s unnecessary to seek a general proof. “In some cases it works and it some cases it doesn’t,’’ says Jütte. “For example, it’s not a cure for cancer.’’

At the centre of this debate is the practice of dilution. Remedies are made by diluting natural substances in alcohol or water to achieve the desired potency. Highly potent medicines are diluted to such an extent that no trace of the original substance remains. How then does it work? Unfortunately, no one knows. The ARH has collaborated with Mumbai’s University Institute of Chemical Technology to carry out research on how drugs with minuscule levels of original material affect the body. “One can say that we know nothing at this moment in time but it is an exciting field for research,’’ says ARH founder Dr SS Apte.

Scientists have suggested that the liquid in which substances are dissolved contain memories of original materials or that the very structure of the liquid could have been altered. Manchanda says, “Perhaps it has some rational basis which we may not know.’’

Date: Until March 18, 10am-6pm
Venue: Association for Research in Homeopathy,
Plot No 24-2/3, Sector 15, Airoli, Navi Mumbai (2769-9646)

Disclaimer: The news story on this page is the copyright of the cited publication. This has been reproduced here for visitors to review, comment on and discuss. This is in keeping with the principle of ‘Fair dealing’ or ‘Fair use’. Visitors may click on the publication name, in the news story, to visit the original article as it appears on the publication’s website.


0
Introducing Digital Practice for Doctors & Healthcare professionals
Swine Flu
National Award for Outstanding achievement by a Non-Professional - Tushar Sampat
Health Professional's Negligence
Health Professional's Negligence
Records of published articles in the newspapers helps common people about precautions to be taken while seeking the services from health professionals and also helps health professionals to rectify the negligence.
read more…
Specialties
Common Symptoms


Aarogya Network

aarogya.com aims to be India’s leading comprehensive health information portal. The site has sections, which cover almost all the medical specialties and give useful information on various diseases. To enhance its reach, the content is available in Indian languages too. We were the first health website to introduce online support groups. Addiction support and Epilepsy support are examples of some very active and vibrant communities.

» Click here to see all our support groups

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

 Get health related new information.

Pune Aarogya
Digital Media Dedicated to Healthcare of Punekars

Health Tools

  • Health Directory
  • Message Board
  • Health Calculators
  • Depression Screening Test

About Aarogya.com

aarogya.com aims to be India’s leading comprehensive health information portal. The site has sections, which cover almost all the medical specialties

Read more...

Suggestions

This is YOUR site, so if you have suggestions or feedback on how we can improve it for you, please let us know! We do our best to keep up!

Read more...

User Comments

“My name is Paulette Conners and I just had to send you an email thanking you since one of the pages on your site was very helpful!”

  • About Us
  • Company Profile
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Feedback
  • Disclaimer
  • Sitemap
  • Invite Your Friends

© 2017 www.aarogya.com. All Rights Reserved.